On Kit (ConvertKit)?

Kit automations or segments acting strangely? We sort it out.

Kit, formerly ConvertKit, is friendly to creators until a visual automation refuses to fire because a tag was renamed last month, a segment reports zero subscribers after a tag merge, or the Gmail promotions tab starts eating broadcasts after a template redesign. Our engineers trace the subscriber path across forms, sequences and visual automations until every tag means what it says, and your deliverability reports stop looking like weather charts.

  • Since 2015Fixing technology
  • FreeEstimates
  • US teamReal engineers

convertkit.log

still broken

What it is

Kit (ConvertKit) at a glance

Kit, formerly ConvertKit, is an email platform for creators founded in 2013 by Nathan Barry. It is tag-based rather than list-based, which makes a single subscriber's state the intersection of forms completed, sequences joined and tags applied.

The audience is bloggers, podcasters, course sellers and newsletter publishers. Features include forms, landing pages, sequences, visual automations, a creator network for cross-recommendations, and a direct Stripe integration for selling digital products. The platform rebranded to Kit in 2024 while retaining the convertkit.com infrastructure.

Type
Creator-focused email marketing platform
First released
2013
License
Proprietary, per-subscriber subscription
Maintained by
Kit (formerly ConvertKit)
Typically used for
Newsletters, course launches, creator sequences, digital-product sales

The honest version

Kit (ConvertKit) pros and cons

No technology is all upside. This is where Kit (ConvertKit) earns its place and where it tends to cause trouble.

Where Kit (ConvertKit) is strong

  • Tag-based audience modelA subscriber is one record with many tags, not a copy on every list. Managing complex audiences without duplicates becomes practical rather than painful.
  • Visual automations read like a diagramTriggers, actions, events and conditions on a single canvas keep nurture logic legible to a non-engineer.
  • Built for creatorsSequences, forms and landing pages are tuned for newsletters and course launches rather than enterprise lifecycle marketing.
  • Creator Network and recommendationsCross-promotion between creators is baked in, which is a growth channel you simply do not get from a general-purpose email tool.
  • Native Stripe productsSelling a digital product, course or tip jar from the same account that runs email removes a chunk of the Teachable-plus-Mailchimp problem.
  • Honest pricing per subscriberCosts track the subscriber count predictably and there are no sudden per-feature upsells on a growth path.

Where Kit (ConvertKit) bites

  • Reporting is lightBroadcast opens and clicks are easy; anything deeper on cohort behavior, revenue attribution or journey-level funnels needs an external tool.
  • Tag sprawl is realA tag-based model without discipline grows into hundreds of tags that nobody can prune without breaking an automation. The platform does not help you spot which ones are stale.
  • Deliverability depends on the sender's disciplineShared sending infrastructure means a broadcast that drives complaints affects your inbox placement. The guardrails are good but not perfect.
  • Not built for ecom lifecycleIf you need cart-abandon, post-purchase and win-back flows on Shopify, Kit is not the right tool; Klaviyo or Omnisend will model that better.
  • A/B testing is basicSubject-line testing is available; body-copy, from-name or send-time testing is weaker than what large-list senders want.
  • Migrations can be bumpyImports from Mailchimp preserve addresses and some tags, but engagement history and automation state do not carry across, which affects re-engagement sends.

Sound familiar?

Common Kit (ConvertKit) problems we fix

The Kit (ConvertKit) problems that bring people to us, and what you have once each one is fixed.

Visual Automation step did not fire

A visual automation skips a step

A tag that was renamed or merged after the automation was built, a condition evaluating against a custom field that is blank, or an event trigger listening to a form that has been archived.

Automation steps firing in order

Segment size changed from 12400 to 0

A segment empties after a bulk tag edit

A tag merge that replaced the id the segment referenced, or an edit that left the segment referencing the deleted tag.

Segment counts match the audience

Broadcast send paused: complaint rate

A broadcast pauses mid-send

A complaint rate above the platform threshold, usually caused by sending to very old subscribers or a list reactivation campaign without proper re-engagement.

Sending resumed with cleaner targeting

Form submission rejected: cooldown

Signup forms silently reject real subscribers

A cooldown rule triggered by rapid repeat submissions from a shared office network, or an incentive form hit by a double-submit from a browser extension.

Legitimate signups accepted

Template rendered without preheader

Broadcast inbox previews look wrong

A template update that removed the preheader element, or a placeholder that renders empty when a merge field is blank.

Preheaders render consistently

Zapier task failed: tag id not found

Zaps break after tag maintenance

A zap that stored a tag id rather than a tag name, pointing at an id that no longer exists after a merge or delete.

Zaps refer to tags that still exist

API: 422 subscriber already subscribed

API imports fail on duplicate subscribers

An import job that does not check for existing subscribers, or a webhook that re-sends a signup event when a form is resubmitted.

Imports handle existing subscribers gracefully

Landing page: reCAPTCHA failed

Landing-page conversions drop silently

A reCAPTCHA failing for real visitors on older browsers, or a site-key mismatch after a domain change.

Landing pages capturing real signups

What we do

Kit (ConvertKit) help, from rescue to upkeep

Ping us for a single stuck automation, or hand us the whole newsletter and product setup.

Rescue
Automations skipping steps, segments reading zero, or broadcasts pausing on complaints. We stabilize the account first and write up the cause second.
Tag taxonomy
Hundreds of tags audited, grouped and documented so the audience model becomes something a new team member can understand.
Deliverability tune-up
Authentication, template structure, list hygiene and sending cadence adjusted so inbox placement stops sliding.
Visual automation design
Welcome sequences, course launches and evergreen funnels built on the canvas with named branches and deliberate goals.
Migrations and imports
Moving from Mailchimp, Substack, or a self-hosted list, with tags mapped and automations rebuilt rather than ported blindly.
Managed Tech
Monthly tag audits, broadcast review sessions, deliverability dashboards and a US engineer to call when a send looks wrong.

How it works

From first message to fixed

  1. Look Free estimate

    Tell us what's going wrong. We look at it, then tell you plainly what's wrong and what it will cost.

  2. Fix

    We fix the cause, not the symptom. If something is down, getting it back up comes first.

  3. Harden

    Backups, monitoring, updates and access, so the same problem can't quietly come back.

  4. Hand back or stay on

    You get a plain-language write-up. Or we stay on for hosting, upkeep and new work.

Often found together

Running Kit (ConvertKit) alongside something else?

We work on the whole stack, so the problem can be wherever it actually is.

Questions

Kit (ConvertKit) questions

Something else? Call+1 737 727 7327

Why did one of my Kit visual automations stop firing?

The three common causes are a tag referenced by the automation that was renamed or merged, a form that was archived while the trigger still pointed at it, and a custom-field condition that evaluates blank for new subscribers. The automation history view on a sample subscriber shows which step they got to and why they stopped.

How do we avoid tag sprawl on Kit?

Agree on a naming convention before new tags are created, keep a short document that lists what each tag is for, and do a quarterly audit that merges or deletes tags that no longer appear in any automation or segment. We run the first audit so your team has a template for the next one.

Why do our broadcasts land in Gmail's promotions tab?

Gmail promotions placement is driven by how the mail looks and how subscribers have historically engaged. Templates heavy in images with little text, a lot of marketing links, and sending to disengaged subscribers all push toward the promotions tab. Adjusting the template, segmenting to engaged subscribers, and warming up the sending domain generally clears it.

Should we be on Kit or Mailchimp?

If you are a creator, course seller or newsletter writer and want tag-based audience logic plus product selling in one place, Kit fits. If you run a general small business with ecom and need broader multi-channel, Mailchimp is still a reasonable default. We help teams make the call based on their actual sends and plans.

Can we sell digital products through Kit?

Yes. Kit Commerce (formerly ConvertKit Commerce) uses Stripe to take payments for digital products, tip jars and paid newsletters. For simple products it removes a layer of tooling; for complex catalogs with inventory or bundles, a dedicated ecommerce platform remains the better fit.

How much does Kit (ConvertKit) help cost?

Estimates come free. Tell us the subscriber count, the automations in play and what has gone off, and a Hawkins.Tech engineer sends a price the same day.

Free estimate

Kit (ConvertKit) giving you trouble?

Tell us the account size, the automations involved and what customers are seeing, and a Hawkins.Tech engineer replies with an estimate.

  • No charge to find out what it will take
  • If it's urgent, say so

Replies come from a person. By sending, you authorize us to email you back. No marketing.